Rocket Fuel Requirements Revisited

In a previous post we looked at the fuel requirements for rockets to reach escape velocity. We calculated the fuel requirements using the rocket equation. This equation takes into account the conservation of momentum. However, momentum is not the only property influencing the velocity of the rocket during a launch.

Rockets expel their fuel over time. During this time, the rocket is pulled back due to gravity. Only if a rocket could instantaneously expel all of its fuel, and when ignoring atmospheric drag, the escape velocity would be reached instantaneously and the equation would hold.

Taking the burn-time and gravity into account yields a difficult differential equation. We can implement that equation in a computer program to simulate the launch.

The equation is of the following form:

$$\frac{dv}{dt} = \frac{dv_e}{dt} + \frac{dv_g}{dt}$$

Here, $dv$ is the total change in velocity, caused by the parts $dv_e$ and $dv_g$, which respectively are the change in velocity due to the exhaust and the change in velocity due to gravity. In the post about the rocket equation, we found:

$$M dv_e = v_e dm$$

$M$ is the mass of the rocket, $dv_e$ is the change in velocity due to the exhaust, $v_e$ is the exhaust velocity and $dm$ is the amount of fuel expelled. Because the instantaneous mass of the expelled fuel $dm$ is equal to the negative instantaneous change of the rocket’s mass, $-dM$, we get:

\begin{aligned} M dv_e &= -v_e dM \\ dv_e &= -\frac{v_e dM}{M} \end{aligned}

Now we will evaluate the function $dv_g$. The force of gravity acting on the rocket due to the Earth is:

$$F_g = -G \frac {M_\oplus M}{r^2}$$

As per usual, $G$ is the gravitational constant. Furthermore, $M_\oplus$ is the mass of the Earth, $M$ is the mass of the rocket, and $r$ is the distance of the rocket to the center of the Earth.

\begin{aligned} F_g &= M a_g = M \frac{dv_g}{dt} \\ \frac{dv_g}{dt} &= a_g = \frac{F_g}{M} \\ &= -G \frac{M_\oplus M}{r^2 M} \\ &= -G \frac{M_\oplus}{r^2} \end{aligned}

Plug the found values into the initial differential equation:

\begin{aligned} \frac{dv}{dt} &= \frac{dv_e}{dt} + \frac{dv_g}{dt} \\ &= -\frac{v_e dM/M}{dt} - G \frac{M_\oplus}{r^2} \\ &= \frac{-v_e dM/dt}{M} - G \frac{M_\oplus}{r^2} \end{aligned}

With the requirement that $v \ge v_e$, where $v_e$ is the escape velocity $\sqrt{2G\frac{M}{r}}$, it becomes clear that this equation is hard to solve by hand. Instead, we will implement the equation in a computer program to simulate it. We’ll use the following values for our digital rocket:

\begin{aligned} M_{dry} &= 2,000 \text{ kg} \\ v_e &= 5,000 \text{ m/s} \\ \frac{dM}{dt} &= -100 \text{ kg/s} \end{aligned}

The last value is the burn-rate of the fuel. For simplicity, we will assume both the exhaust velocity and the burn-rate remain constant during the launch. After running the program for multiple initial rocket masses (i.e., different amounts of fuel), we find that the rocket requires roughly $24.5 \text{ tonnes}$ worth of fuel to escape Earth’s gravity completely, which is a lot more than the $19 \text{ tonnes}$ found with the naive calculation in the previous post.

The graphs of the height, velocity, and acceleration versus time can be seen below. With this configuration, during the final seconds of the launch, the rocket reached an acceleration of nearly 25 g’s. Such high forces are incredibly dangerous for humans. Therefore, if this were a real spacecraft carrying humans, it would be vital to throttle down during the final stage of the launch.

Update 2018-11-28: the simulation has been reimplemented in JavaScript, you can interact with it here:

3 thoughts on “Rocket Fuel Requirements Revisited”

I think the equation seems to be solvable by hand if the fuel gets burnt in a short duration that distance of rocket from earth can be approximated to Earths’s radius till all fuel is burnt:
dv/dt = -Ve dM/dt /M -GMe/r**2

dv = -Ve DM/M – GMe.dt/r**2
Applying definite integral to above equation
Vf-Vi = Ve . log ((Mrkt+Mfuel)/Mrkt) -GMe.Tburn/r**2

Where Tburn = Mfuel/Burnrate of fuel

Please let me know if you see a problem in above derivation

1. Your derivation looks good! I wrote another post to evaluate this idea and arrived at the same equation, see here: https://churchman.nl/2018/11/28/closed-form-rocket-fuel-requirements/

Further, I created interactive tools for both the simulation and your closed-form solution, so differences in results can be seen intuitively. With the rocket parameters used in this post series, it seems the closed-form quite heavily overestimates fuel requirements.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.